Is Scandinavian politics just about free education, free healthcare, long maternity/paternity leave and high taxes to pay for all of this? Lately many non-Scandinavians have pointed to Scandinavia–either as a political system to copy or something to scare people with … because, you know, socialism.
The Norwegian parliament, built in LEGO, can be seen inside the Norwegian parliament. Notice the protesters in front of the parliament – they’re an important part of our democracy.
So are the Scandinavian Social Democracies (we do not call them socialist democracies, for the record) just about a lot of free stuff and high taxes? Definitely not. The Scandinavian Social Democracies are complicated systems that depend on a number of small parts to make them work. I’ll run through those small parts here.
These points come from a lecture I heard a while back by Yngvar Åsholt from the Norwegian employment- and welfareorganization NAV. I use Norway as my example but Sweden and Denmark have the same system, with minor differences.
Well organized work force based on negotiations
In many countries unions are seen as a bad thing. Not so in Scandinavia. I’m an employer myself and I love the unions because they give me a well organized opportunity to discuss and negotiate big changes with the employees, which again gives me and the company happier employees. Happy employees are an asset so even if you’re just thinking with your wallet, you should welcome anything that makes your employees happier. You might also consider thinking with your heart and not just your wallet.
Did the Vikings have unions? Were they happy with their Earl?
Unions are not just important locally but also on state level. The Scandinavian countries practice something called the three-party-cooperation where the unions, the employer organizations and the government negotiate big changes to pensions, wages, maternity/paternity leaves, vacations etc. The unions speak for the employees, the employer organizations speak for the employers and the businesses and the state tries to keep spending low and satisfaction high. These yearly or bi-yearly negotiations are incredibly important and there’s a system surrounding them to make sure it’s a give and take on all three parties.
Norway has a right-wing/conservative/Christian Democrats/Liberal party (yes, four parties) government and one would think they would do anything to crush the unions. This is not the case. In fact, this is a quote by the Norwegian Prime Minister:
The three-party-cooperation is our competitive advantage.
Why? Because it creates stability and all three parties are relatively happy–none of the parties get everything they want but all of them get something. It also makes it possible to solve larger problems. Right now with the oil prices going down, Norway does not need a huge wage rise. So the three-party-cooperation agreed on holding wages back. This would not be possible if the CEOs awarded themselves huge bonuses so this is part of the deal–everyone hold back, not just the employees.
Universal benefits and comprehensive public service
If you reach a certain age and you’ve worked for a certain number of years, you will get a pension. If you have a child and you’ve been working, you will have paid maternity/paternity leave and your child will have a monthly payment from the state. If you choose to study, it’s free and you will receive grants from the state. If you’re unemployed, you get unemployment benefits. If you’re sick, you get sick pay and free health care. If you have a disability that makes it hard for you to be on the work force, you get disability payment. And so on and so forth.
Free health care and paid sick leave – and, of course, cheap health care – are all important in Scandinavia
You don’t have to buy insurances (actually, in Denmark you do have to have sort-of an unemployment insurance through your union) to get these benefits. You don’t have to know someone who knows someone. The rules are for everyone.
On top of that, we have cheap child care, free schools, subsidized public transportation, nurses and other health care workers who help older citizens who live at home, and retirement homes that are free or fairly cheap and a huge number of other kinds of public services.
These benefits and services are important because they may seem kind, but they’re also one of the reasons why our economy is running so well. With great child care and senior citizen care, more people can go to work, knowing that their children or their parents are well looked after. Norway’s former Prime Minister, Jens Stoltenberg, said that it wasn’t the oil that made Norway so prosperous, it was the huge amount of women in the work force.
The safety net ensures that noone is left behind and everyone is cared for. Less worries and more happy citizens.
Redistribution
The Scandinavian countries are unique when it comes to redistributing wealth. Not just through taxes but also because it’s just not acceptable for a CEO to earn several hundred times more than one of the workers in his or her company, as we see it in some countries.
Norway is the country in Europe with the least difference between rich and poor.
Taxes are not unpopular. We see the benefits of paying our taxes, both from what we receive from the state ourselves and the knowledge that we have a safety net if we are ever sick, unemployed or otherwise in need of help.
Egalitarian societies
The redistribution of wealth and the three-party-cooperation are just two reasons why the Scandinavian countries are fairly egalitarian. Yes, we do have some super-rich families, like most other countries, but in general we’re pretty much alike. Some are a little better off than others but in general we have very few poor people and very few rich people.
High employment rate
We may not work a lot of hours–long vacations and short work weeks will see to that–but a lot of us do work. We have one of the highest employment rates in the world. Both men and women work all their lives and we do not retire early.
High rate of education
With free education, and even government grants to live on, no wonder a lot of young Scandinavians choose to study. One would think that we would end up with too many people with high education and no jobs for them, but the funny thing is that the more people you have with high education, the more jobs they create.
It’s also great for business when a country can offer a highly educated staff to foreign countries looking to invest.
High rate of productivity
With long vacations, short work weeks and unions butting in on all the major decisions, you might think we don’t get anything done here in Scandinavia. You would be wrong.
We are highly productive.
Where you might have to hire three people in other countries, you only need two here. Our GNP pr capita is very high because we get things done even though we leave the office at four to pick up our kids.
Stability and predictability
It’s easy to take risks in a country where you know you have a safety net. It’s easy to start up a business when you know that the rules that govern businesses today will be the same tomorrow. It’s easy to trust customers or other companies when you know that the judicial system will protect you from wrong doing.
People trust the system–and each other
We pay our taxes because we know that everyone else does. And our taxes aren’t as high as you would think, considering what we get in return. I pay 31% of my wages in taxes, and I’m considered a high-tax payer.
Our health care is fairly cheap compared to the US because it is cheaper when noone is getting rich on other peoples’ bad health.
We also know that there are systems that ensure that our tax kroners are used for whatever the politicians promised they would use them for, and that anyone can check up on any decisions made by a government agency.
We have laws that ensure that anyone can ask for almost any document or letter written by any government official.
Trust and transparency are incredibly important to ensure that people still want to pay their taxes, that people will take risks when it comes to starting businesses or getting new jobs, that people will enter partnerships and share information etc.
I really wish the US could be more like that. I don’t believe anything coming out of a pilitians mouth. They whole system has been abused and flawed. I don’t mind paying my fair share of taxes but when you see millionaires paying less tax than you or someone on welfare that isn’t even a legal resident living better than you you become bitter and jaded.
How can out congressmen make approximately $150,000 to 200,000 per year afford a Gulftream 650 plane?
I would love to fire all of the politicians. Implement term limits and have more than two parties. I know that technically we have more than two parties but if you’re not a democratic or a republican you won’t be elected. Greed and laziness has corrupted Our lawmakers. It’s a sad state of affairs.
I think people would only be willing to pay taxes if they feel everyone–including the very rich–pay their fair share. This is why it’s so dangerous when they change the tax laws so that the rich pay less.
I also think it’s important to work for a system where politicians choose to become politicians because they want to do good, not to get rich or powerful. Which is why they shouldn’t earn more than a normal wage. I mean, they should make a desent living, but not become billionaires.